Discrete element method (DEM) has been intensively used to study the constitutive behaviour of granular materials. However, to what extent a real granular material can be reproduced by virtual DEM simulations remains unclear. This study attempts to answer this question by comparing DEM simulations with typical features of experimental granular materials. Three groups of models with spherical and clumped particles are investigated from four perspectives: (i) deviatoric stress and volumetric behaviour; (ii) critical state behaviour; (iii) stress-dilatancy relationship; and (iv) the evolution of principal stress ratio against axial strain. The results demonstrate that DEM with spherical or clumped particles is capable of qualitatively describing macroscopic deviatoric stress responses, volumetric behaviour, and critical state behaviour observed in experiments for granular materials. On the other hand, some qualitative deviations between experiments and the investigated DEM simulations are also observed, in terms of the stress-dilatancy behaviour and principal stress ratio against axial strain, which are proven to be critical for constitutive modelling. The results demonstrate that DEM with spherical or clumped particles may not necessarily fully capture experimental features of granular materials even from a qualitative perspective. It is thus encouraged to thoroughly validate DEM with experiments when developing constitutive models based on DEM observations.

Download PDF:

Keywords: Discrete element method (DEM), Granular materials, Constitutive behaviour, Deviatoric hardening model, Rolling resistance model, Irregular particles